Tangem Wallet Pack of 2 - Secure Crypto Wallet - Trusted Cold Storage for Bitcoin, Ethereum, NFT's &

Tangem Wallet Pack of 2 - Secure Crypto Wallet - Trusted Cold Storage for Bitcoin, Ethereum, NFT's &
Key item features Ultimate Security: Generates a private key that remains on the card, safeguarding crypto and NFTs from hackers with EAL6+ certification and audited firmware. Versatile Compatibility: Manages over 13,000 tokens across 70+ blockchains, supporting DeFi, NFTs, and DeEx without wires, Bluetooth, or USB. Effortless Operation: Utilizes NFC for secure transactions via a mobile device and the Tangem app, enabling buying and selling crypto with various payment methods. Smart Backup: Features a second Tangem Wallet as a backup, eliminating the need for paper, pictures, or seed phrases for recovery. Durable Design: Boasts IP68 protection against environmental conditions, ensuring longevity and robust physical security. Comprehensive Support: Compatible with Bitcoin, Ethereum, Solana, XRP, USDT, and over 6,000 cryptocurrencies, integrating with dApps and WalletConnect.

LBANK

Why the witness commitment is optional?

So as can be read in BIP141 the witness commitment is optional:

If all transactions in a block do not have witness data, the commitment is optional.

But why?

We have a known issue that could lead to coinbase transactions having the same txid. Which is a problem because it can lead to make coins impossible to spend. Those cases are not covered by BIP34 and as far as I know BIP30 is no longer in use. See this resources for the collision cases.

Seems that making the witness commitment mandatory would solve it as the txid would change. Why was this rule not enforced since the beginning? I could understand that you don't want to force people to upgrade instantly to segwit and cause a fork on the chain but in that case, why it is not enforced now when all miners are running segwit so avoid a possible attack?



from Recent Questions - Bitcoin Stack Exchange https://ift.tt/SKfuGPQ
via IFTTT

Popular posts from this blog

Crypto Exec Warns Tokenization Is Moving Faster Than Expected

Bitcoin Mining Could Be Strengthening The Ruble, Russian Central Bank Says

Nigerian SEC Partners With Police To Tackle Crypto Ponzi Schemes – Details